On the night of June 29, 1999, a man was walking home from a Narcotics Anonymous meeting after getting married earlier that day when he reported that a man approached him and robbed him at gunpoint. The victim said the perpetrator took his wedding ring and a gold necklace.
A few hours later, police stopped a vehicle for erratic driving several miles away. During the stop, an officer saw a gold necklace in the vehicle and noted that one passenger, Tavares Hutchinson, appeared to match the robbery suspect’s description. The primary similarities were that Tavares was a Black man and had a gold necklace in his possession. Tavares told officers that he had purchased the necklace and denied committing the robbery. Police did not find the victim’s wedding ring or a gun in Tavares’ possession.
After the traffic stop, officers took the necklace found in the vehicle to the victim, who identified it as the necklace that had been stolen. Police then conducted a single-person show-up identification at the location of the traffic stop, where the victim identified Tavares as the person who had robbed him.
Significant differences between Tavares and the victim’s original description of the perpetrator were later identified. Tavares did not match the reported age, height, weight, clothing, speech pattern, or appearance of the perpetrator’s teeth. Tavares also had visible scars and an obvious physical deformity that the victim had not described.
Years later, eyewitness identification expert Dr. Lora Levett, past president of the American Psychology-Law Society, reviewed the identification procedure and identified 12 different infirmities in the composition and administration of the show-up that further undermined the reliability of the identification.
On January 19, 2000, Tavares was found guilty of robbery with a weapon and resisting without violence. The case against him rested on the victim’s single-person show-up identification and his identification of the necklace found in the vehicle.
Years later, a reinvestigation revealed that the necklace recovered from the vehicle was materially different from the victim’s description of his stolen necklace. The victim described his necklace as a 14-karat gold, Gucci-style necklace with small holes, silver qualities, and a unique pendant on the clasp. The necklace collected from the vehicle was determined to be fake gold, Figaro-style, without holes, entirely yellow in color, and without the distinctive pendant.
Tavares ultimately spent more than 26 years incarcerated while maintaining that he did not commit the robbery.
In February 2024, Tavares asked the Broward Conviction Review Unit (CRU) within the State Attorney’s Office to review his claim of factual innocence. The CRU asked the Innocence Project of Florida to assist, and IPF took Tavares on as a client. IPF Legal Director Brandon Scheck represented him.
During a collaborative reinvestigation supported by a joint U.S. Department of Justice grant, IPF and the CRU developed significant evidence undermining the conviction and supporting Tavares’ claim of factual innocence. In addition to determining that the necklace recovered by police was not consistent with the victim’s stolen necklace, investigators examined serious problems with the eyewitness identification and discrepancies between Tavares and the original description of the perpetrator.
Importantly, the victim had independently provided two sworn affidavits in 2020 recanting his identification of Tavares and stating his belief that Tavares was innocent. In a 2025 sworn statement to the CRU, he again affirmed that he had misidentified Tavares. He also reported that a woman had later come to his home and said she found his identification card in the possession of her brother, who matched the perpetrator’s description. The CRU was unable to establish a connection between either individual and Tavares.
The reinvestigation also raised questions about whether the reported robbery occurred as originally described. Witness statements and inconsistencies in the victim’s accounts left open the possibility that the necklace and wedding ring had been sold and the robbery subsequently reported.
Despite the evidence developed during the reinvestigation, the State did not vacate Tavares’ conviction. Instead, after IPF filed a motion for postconviction relief containing evidence of actual innocence, the State agreed to resentence him to time served. Facing the possibility of otherwise remaining incarcerated for the rest of his life, Tavares accepted the offer while continuing to maintain his innocence.
On November 14, 2025, Tavares walked out of the Broward County Jail after more than 26 years of wrongful incarceration. He became the 37th person released with the help of the Innocence Project of Florida. Because his conviction was not vacated, Tavares remains wrongfully convicted, and IPF continues to advocate for fully rectifying his conviction.
Although we are the premier resource in Florida for those who have been wrongfully convicted and imprisoned, we receive no funding from the State of Florida. Our continued operation depends on the generosity of friends like you.