Incident Date: June 25, 1982
Jurisdiction: Sixteenth Circuit
Charge: Att. Sexual Battery, Burglary
Conviction: Att. Sexual Battery, Burglary
Sentence: 50 Years
Year of Conviction: 1983
Exoneration Date: May 23, 2006
Sentence Served: 13 Years
Real perpetrator found? Not Yet
Contributing Causes: Eyewitness Misidentification
Compensation? Not Yet
On May 23, 2006, Orlando Boquete’s conviction for attempted sexual battery and burglary was vacated. DNA testing on the victim’s clothing proved that he was not the man who committed the crime. His release from state custody was delayed until August 22, 2006, when he was released from the custody of the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agency.
In the early morning hours of June 25, 1982, two Latino men broke into the victim’s apartment in Stock Island, Florida. When the victim woke up, one man was on top of her on her bed, with his hand over her mouth. He sexually assaulted her, depositing semen on her clothing. The first perpetrator was described as Latino with no shirt and no hair. The second perpetrator did not enter the victim’s bedroom at any point.
Within minutes of the incident, an officer stopped several Cuban-American men in a convenience store parking lot. Only Orlando Boquete had no hair and no shirt. The victim identified Boquete as her attacker from 20 feet away as he was in a police car. Boquete had a large, black moustache at the time of his arrest. After identifying Boquete, the victim added to her description that the attacker had a moustache. A second man was also identified at the convenience store as the man who had not entered the victim’s room.
At trial, Boquete testified that he had been home the entire evening with his family, watching sports, until he went to the convenience store with his cousins.
The Biological Evidence
Police collected the victim’s underwear and pajama top, both of which had semen stains on them. She told police that she was sure that the semen had come from the perpetrator. No further forensic testing was performed at the time of trial.
In 2003, Boquete filed a motion on his own seeking DNA testing on semen stains on the victim’s clothing. In 2004, the State consented to DNA testing and the judge ordered the evidence sent to a lab. In November 2005, Orchid Cellmark, a private laboratory, conducted the tests pro bono. The testing concluded that Boquete could not be the source of the semen on the woman’s underwear. No results were obtained for her pajama top. Boquete’s conviction was overturned on May 23, 2006, with full cooperation from the Monroe County State’s Attorney, Mark Kohl. As he had escaped from custody in 1983 for ten years, and again in 1995 for one year, the Immigrations and Customs Enforcement Agency detained him upon his release from prison until August 22, 2006.